What does the number of comments you receive on your blog post indicate to others? Yourself?
There are so many great examples of super interesting bloggers that can ignite conversation amongst a community of readers. But, I’m interested in uncovering examples of very popular online figures who receive very few comments.
So I ask the question…
Can you really be successful and have few or zero comments from others?
Let’s take a look at two very talented and successful online entrepreneurs. First, Daisy Whitney of New Media Minute and secondly, Laura Fitton or more commonly known on Twitter as @pistachio.
Daisy Whitney is one of the first multimedia reporter and journalists to launch her own online newscast covering the business of internet video. Her webcast show New Media Minute is carried on many top networks including ABCNews.com and TVWeek.com. This Brown University Art History graduate is breaking new ground as an internet entrepreneur.
What’s interesting is she has very few comments posted on her wonderful videos.
Could it be that because her videos are re-purposed across different networks that might explain why she receives few comments on her website? Maybe people who watch online videos are less prone to comment compared to bloggers who write their message? Maybe?

Are you familiar with Laura Fitton more commonly known as @pistachio on Twitter?
Laura was already widely known before Seth Godin mentioned her in his book Tribes. I’m sure that did not hurt her by having now almost 27,000 followers paying attention to her consistent Twitter updates throughout the day.
Would you be surprised to know that she has very few comments on her personal blog?
Could it be because most are following her Twitter comments and are less interested in her blog? Maybe?

How does this apply to small business owners who may not have a huge following?
I believe in the following ways:
- Impression, credibility and commenting . What matters most is when your ideal prospects and customers arrive at your site they are provided with a web presence providing them with opportunity to get to know, like, and trust you. I have witnessed first-hand that your content can be wonderful and be perceived as a virtual agency and people will not always feel the need to contribute their opinion to your community of readers. Especially in this day and age where many people are reading to consume and not participate. To participate takes time and thought, both are lacking in our increasingly busy and stressful day.
- Physical Action vs. Discussion. Many people struggle to get people to take a physical action in their blog posts. For example, you write a blog post and invite people to comment & share their thoughts on this post. Many more people really struggle with creating a physical action (ex-”click on this link or “add to shopping cart) leading people to a product or service. There is still a feeling that you should not “sell” on your blog posts. If you don’t tactfully tell your ideal readers what you would like for them to consider doing, you can almost be certain they will do little.
- Blogs are the new websites. More and more small business owners are finding a Word Press template they love and with relatively little technical support are up and running with a beautiful and potentially “spider” search engine optimized site. Since blogs often serve as a new primary website, I believe you must create consistent and relevant changing content, but I don’t think it matters as much as before if your company online store front (blog) does not contain a ton of comments in the blog section. If your goal is to become a well-known community blogger, of course it is critically important to empower and succeed at having people comment on your blog posts.
- You might not be that interesting. Of course, what you write about may not be worthy of anyone taking the time to comment.
In my own personal experience, I have little success in building a community of readers who decide to comment on my blog posts. However, I’ve been very successful in converting my readers into clients or paid customers.
I think the best case scenario is to have a blog focusing on a market relevant topic for your version of an ideal client where your communication skills (text, audio, video) ignite conversation and tactfully give your ideal client the opportunity to uncover for themselves what they would like to do next and perhaps even what you would like for them to do next.
I’d like you to comment on this post. But if you are too busy, distracted or even dis-interested, I understand.
Perhaps you would like to buy something from me while you are waiting for something to say
?


You know what? I get relatively few comments on my blog — but I have a ton of readers and people write me emails constantly mentioning something I’ve written. My blog posts are more like short magazine columns than conversation starters — and people like to relate to me 1:1 via email, FB and Twitter. I seem to have a system that works because I am booked solid and my community is happy. They’re just not terrifically talkative in the blog space. Thanks for a great gut check, though. You’ve written something very important.
Michele,
I agree with your comments.
Today, compared to just a year ago, the number of comments received on a blog post means less. Partly because of how busy people are today, and I think because so many of us, including our firm, use our blog as a website vs. just a traditional blog.
Appreciate you taking time to share your thoughts.
Just like anything else, there are reasons and causes for comments or a lack thereof that can be focused on and manipulated. The thing is, it takes effort. Your point here, as I take it, is that fostering that kind of discussion isn’t always the best use of the effort and not the only sign of a good blog.
Many of the blogs with a ton of comments are boring. Some of my favorites get very little discussion.
So is it better to take off comments? Is there a perception of your new reader that “wow, this guy must be a dud – no one ever comments” vs. having people focus more on the content than on the arbitrary “# of Comments”? I keep leaving mine one in the event a good discussion gets going, but for the most part I get few comments. Of course like you said, I get more comments face-to-face or on Twitter (@marketingtwins) or on Facebook. Had a client with the same concern – so much so that he was wanting to transcribe Facebook comments (he’d import his blog posts as NOTES into FB) into his blog just to show that people were conversing about his thoughts – just not on his blog!
@Randy, good question.
I don’t recommend anyone remove comment section. Step #1 of receiving blog comments is to offer the opportunity for someone to leave comments. Obviously, Step #2 is conversation worthy content, followed by Step #3 encouraging a physical call to action.
I most often ask my readers to take a physical action (mouse click) towards a live event.
I have discovered if I ask readers to do more than one thing they either are confused or just will not do it. So, I opt for my one-thing to be a live event, so they may get hopefully have a more personal way to get to know me and our offerings.
hm. informative ))